by milkyaqua » Thu Mar 11, 2010 8:46 pm
My comment had nothing to do with being negative.
I'm just stating an opinion based on previous info. Why would Tina release material from several years ago when at the time she was deliberately trying to get material that would get airplay? I think it's a good guess that the Chambers boat has sailed. I will say that I agree that this song not being given to Tina is no big loss. The whole Soul Survivor connotates I Might Have Been Queen and yes, "been there, done that" and that was a better song than this one. Although it fits into the whole pop with some r&b thrown in that seems to be Tina's (or Roger's) standard.
I also happened to like the Edith and The Kingpin project as well but agree that a fair amount of her fans (at least on these forums) doesn't seem to want her to go down that road. However, if you're being practical about it (and based on past interviews) Tina herself is at a point in her career where she probably wouldn't mind doing it or something similar to it but seems to know the fans are resistant to it. I think that's a little sad.
It'll be interesting to hear what she comes up with when she decides to go back into the studio. I'll be glad to hear anything new from her but like this past tour, I'll be disappointed if it turns out to be the tried and true and not something different.